Musings: The Strange Magic of Getting Stuck
Getting stuck is one of the most irritating parts of writing.
You sit down, sure you had a good idea five minutes ago. Maybe even a great one.
And now? Nothing.
Just you, a blinking cursor, and a sudden urge to do literally anything else. Clean a drawer. Wipe down the counters. Fold a load of laundry. Very urgent. Very necessary.
Am I right?
Writers love to talk about inspiration. Flow. Voice. Those magical days when the words pour out like you’ve been personally kissed by the muse.
What we talk about a lot less is getting stuck. Because getting stuck feels like failure. It feels like proof that your idea was flimsy, your talent has packed a bag, and the writing gods have wandered off to help somebody else.
But the more I write, the more I think getting stuck is not always the enemy.
Sometimes getting stuck is the work.
I went down a little rabbit hole on this, (Because I was stuck. Cue the irony.) and found that psychologists have a name for one piece of it: the incubation effect. The basic idea is that stepping away from a problem can actually help you solve it later. You know how you get your best ideas in the shower? Thank the incubation effect.
That makes perfect sense to me.
When I get stuck, it usually is not because I have nothing to say. It is because I am trying to shove the piece into a box where it doesn’t belong.
I have an opening I like.
A point I want to make.
A neat little path I planned out.
And the piece, being obstinate, refuses to cooperate.
So I do what many writers do. I fuss with a sentence. Swap a word. Move a comma. Stare harder. As if the sentence is the problem. Usually, the sentence is not the problem. Usually, I am.
Sometimes I started in the wrong place. Sometimes I’m skating around the real point because I would rather not poke at it. Sometimes I try to sound polished when I should sound true.
No wonder the whole thing grinds to a halt.
And don’t even get me started on perfectionism (Perfectionism = Fear in a nicer outfit.)
General wisdom on writer’s block basically says the usual suspects are perfectionism, procrastination, and unrealistic expectations. Which sounds about right.
A lot of the time, we are not stuck because we have nothing to say. We are stuck because we would like to say it brilliantly on the first try, which is both charmingly clueless and ridiculous.
Procrastination is not usually laziness either. The psychology on that is pretty clear: it is often about emotion.
We avoid things that make us feel uncertain, exposed, overwhelmed, or incompetent. So suddenly folding towels feels like a serious contribution to society because it does not ask nearly as much of us as telling the truth on the page.
But here is the useful part.
Getting stuck can mean the easy version is too shallow. It can mean the piece has a false note in it.
It can mean you are trying to write the tidy version while the real version sits a few feet to your left, arms crossed, waiting for you to stop dancing around and start digging.
That is where the magic is.
Not pretty magic. Not candlelight and silk-scarf magic. More like muttering, wearing sweatpants, and delete, delete, delete.
The kind where you stop pushing so hard.
Work on something different, go take a shower, unload the dishwasher. While you’re distracted by the mundane, the line or direction you actually need might show up.
It then that you realize the piece is not about the small thing you started with at all. Not the recipe card. Not the carousel. Not the road trip. Not the funny family story.
It is about grief. Or regret. Or longing. Or envy. Or the ways we keep trying to turn a messy life into a neat little story with a beginning, middle, and end.
That is what getting stuck can do.
It makes you wait long enough to find out what you are really writing about.
Easy writing is lovely when it happens. I love it when I am in the flow and I can’t type fast enough. I have zero interest in artistic suffering. I never aspired to be an underfed poet in a drafty attic.
But easy writing is not always the best writing. Sometimes the quick version is the safe version. Sometimes the smooth sentence is just your way of distancing yourself from the messier truth.
Getting stuck slows you down. It makes you ask better questions.
What am I really trying to say?
What am I avoiding?
Why does this part feel flat?
Why does one sentence feel alive while the rest of the page just sits there like cold mashed potatoes?
That is not failure. That is the dig.
And yes, sometimes a piece is just not working. Sometimes it needs to be shoved in a drawer and left there to think about its choices. This is where you let your subconscious set a spell and take a long think. Often, you will find the diamonds that were there all along.
Stuck is not the end. It is the moment where the writing stops letting you fake it.
So now, when I get stuck, I don’t panic. I don’t let imposter syndrome pipe up and tell me I should quit writing and take up a hobby with less emotional exposure.
I try to remember that maybe the piece just is not ready to be easy.
Maybe it wants more. More honesty. Less laziness. No complacency. And annoying as that is, maybe that is exactly where the good stuff starts.
Embrace your stuck.
It’s the universe telling you that a better version is coming.
